African Court Cases

Fatsah Ouguergouz

Opinions of Judge — Fatsah Ouguergouz

23 contentious · 1 advisory

# Opinions Opinion Type Action
1 App 001/2008 — Michelot Yogogombaye vs Republic of Senegal| Rulings (Jurisdiction)(15 Dec 2009) Separate Opinion
2 App 008/2011 — Ekollo Moundi Alexandre vs Federal Republic of Nigeria| Rulings (Jurisdiction)(23 Sep 2011) Dissenting Opinion
3 App 010/2011 — Pr. Efoua Mbozo’o Samwel vs The Pan- African Parliament| Rulings (Jurisdiction)(30 Sep 2011) Separate Opinion
4 App 012/2011 — La Convention Nationale des Syndicats du Secteur Education (CONASYSED) vs Republic of Gabon| Rulings (Jurisdiction)(15 Dec 2011) Separate Opinion
5 App 004/2012 — Emmanuel Joseph Uko and Others vs Republic of South Africa| Rulings (Jurisdiction)(30 Mar 2012) Separate Opinion
6 App 005/2012 — Amir Adam Timan vs Republic of the Sudan| Rulings (Jurisdiction)(30 Mar 2012) Separate Opinion
7 App 002/2012 — Delta International Investments S.A., Mr and Mrs A.G.L. De Lange vs Republic of South Africa| Rulings (Jurisdiction)(30 Mar 2012) Dissenting Opinion
8 App 007/2012 — Baghdadi Ali Mahmoudi vs Republic of Tunisia| Rulings (Jurisdiction)(26 Jun 2012) Separate Opinion
9 App 001/2011 — Femi Falana vs The African Union| Rulings (Jurisdiction)(26 Jun 2012) Separate Opinion
10 App 009/2011 — The Tanganyika Law Society and Legal and Human Rights Centre vs United Republic of Tanzania| Judgments (Merits)(14 Jun 2013) Separate Opinion
11 App 011/2011 — Rev. Christopher Mtikila vs United Republic of Tanzania| Judgments (Merits)(14 Jun 2013) Separate Opinion
12 App 003/2011 — Urban Mkandawire vs Republic of Malawi| Judgments (Review)(21 Jun 2013) Separate Opinion
13 App 003/2012 — Peter Joseph Chacha vs United Republic of Tanzania| Rulings (Admissibility)(28 Mar 2014) Dissenting Opinion
14 App 003/2011 — Urban Mkandawire vs Republic of Malawi| Judgments (Interpretation)(28 Mar 2014) Separate Opinion
15 App 001/2012 — Frank David Omary and others vs United Republic of Tanzania| Rulings (Admissibility)(28 Mar 2014) Separate Opinion
16 App 003/2012 — Peter Joseph Chacha vs United Republic of Tanzania| Rulings (Admissibility)(28 Mar 2014) Dissenting Opinion
17 App 002/2013 — The African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights vs Libya| Rulings (Provisional measures)(10 Aug 2015) Separate Opinion
18 App 019/2015 — Barrister Femi Falana ESQ vs African Commission on Human and People’s Rights| Rulings (Jurisdiction)(20 Nov 2015) Separate Opinion
19 App 003/2014 — Ingabire Victoire Umuhoza vs Republic of Rwanda| Orders (Procedure)(18 Mar 2016) Dissenting Opinion
20 App 001/2012 — Frank David Omary and others vs United Republic of Tanzania| Judgments (Review)(03 Jun 2016) Separate Opinion
21 App 002/2013 — The African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights vs Libya| Judgments (Merits)(03 Jun 2016) Separate Opinion
22 App 003/2014 — Ingabire Victoire Umuhoza vs Republic of Rwanda| Rulings (Jurisdiction)(03 Jun 2016) Separate Opinion
23 App 001/2014 — APDH vs Republic of Cote d’Ivoire| Judgments (Merits)(18 Nov 2016) Separate Opinion
Advisory proceedings
1 Order on Request for Advisory Opinion No 001/2015 On Whether the treaty obligations of an African State party to the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court (ICC) to cooperate with the ICC is superior to the obligation of that State to comply with African Union Resolutions calling for non-cooperation of its members with the ICC, Requested by Coalition for the International Criminal Court, the Legal Defence and Assistance Project, the Civil Resource Development and Documentation Centre (CIRDDOC) and the Women Advocates Documentation Centre (WARDC) (29 Nov 2015) Dissenting Opinion

Contentious opinions

1 App 001/2008 — Michelot Yogogombaye vs Republic of Senegal| Rulings (Jurisdiction)(15 Dec 2009)
Opinion Type Separate Opinion
2 App 008/2011 — Ekollo Moundi Alexandre vs Federal Republic of Nigeria| Rulings (Jurisdiction)(23 Sep 2011)
Opinion Type Dissenting Opinion
3 App 010/2011 — Pr. Efoua Mbozo’o Samwel vs The Pan- African Parliament| Rulings (Jurisdiction)(30 Sep 2011)
Opinion Type Separate Opinion
4 App 012/2011 — La Convention Nationale des Syndicats du Secteur Education (CONASYSED) vs Republic of Gabon| Rulings (Jurisdiction)(15 Dec 2011)
Opinion Type Separate Opinion
5 App 004/2012 — Emmanuel Joseph Uko and Others vs Republic of South Africa| Rulings (Jurisdiction)(30 Mar 2012)
Opinion Type Separate Opinion
6 App 005/2012 — Amir Adam Timan vs Republic of the Sudan| Rulings (Jurisdiction)(30 Mar 2012)
Opinion Type Separate Opinion
7 App 002/2012 — Delta International Investments S.A., Mr and Mrs A.G.L. De Lange vs Republic of South Africa| Rulings (Jurisdiction)(30 Mar 2012)
Opinion Type Dissenting Opinion
8 App 007/2012 — Baghdadi Ali Mahmoudi vs Republic of Tunisia| Rulings (Jurisdiction)(26 Jun 2012)
Opinion Type Separate Opinion
9 App 001/2011 — Femi Falana vs The African Union| Rulings (Jurisdiction)(26 Jun 2012)
Opinion Type Separate Opinion
10 App 009/2011 — The Tanganyika Law Society and Legal and Human Rights Centre vs United Republic of Tanzania| Judgments (Merits)(14 Jun 2013)
Opinion Type Separate Opinion
11 App 011/2011 — Rev. Christopher Mtikila vs United Republic of Tanzania| Judgments (Merits)(14 Jun 2013)
Opinion Type Separate Opinion
12 App 003/2011 — Urban Mkandawire vs Republic of Malawi| Judgments (Review)(21 Jun 2013)
Opinion Type Separate Opinion
13 App 003/2012 — Peter Joseph Chacha vs United Republic of Tanzania| Rulings (Admissibility)(28 Mar 2014)
Opinion Type Dissenting Opinion
14 App 003/2011 — Urban Mkandawire vs Republic of Malawi| Judgments (Interpretation)(28 Mar 2014)
Opinion Type Separate Opinion
15 App 001/2012 — Frank David Omary and others vs United Republic of Tanzania| Rulings (Admissibility)(28 Mar 2014)
Opinion Type Separate Opinion
16 App 003/2012 — Peter Joseph Chacha vs United Republic of Tanzania| Rulings (Admissibility)(28 Mar 2014)
Opinion Type Dissenting Opinion
17 App 002/2013 — The African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights vs Libya| Rulings (Provisional measures)(10 Aug 2015)
Opinion Type Separate Opinion
18 App 019/2015 — Barrister Femi Falana ESQ vs African Commission on Human and People’s Rights| Rulings (Jurisdiction)(20 Nov 2015)
Opinion Type Separate Opinion
19 App 003/2014 — Ingabire Victoire Umuhoza vs Republic of Rwanda| Orders (Procedure)(18 Mar 2016)
Opinion Type Dissenting Opinion
20 App 001/2012 — Frank David Omary and others vs United Republic of Tanzania| Judgments (Review)(03 Jun 2016)
Opinion Type Separate Opinion
21 App 002/2013 — The African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights vs Libya| Judgments (Merits)(03 Jun 2016)
Opinion Type Separate Opinion
22 App 003/2014 — Ingabire Victoire Umuhoza vs Republic of Rwanda| Rulings (Jurisdiction)(03 Jun 2016)
Opinion Type Separate Opinion
23 App 001/2014 — APDH vs Republic of Cote d’Ivoire| Judgments (Merits)(18 Nov 2016)
Opinion Type Separate Opinion

Advisory proceedings

1 Order on Request for Advisory Opinion No 001/2015 On Whether the treaty obligations of an African State party to the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court (ICC) to cooperate with the ICC is superior to the obligation of that State to comply with African Union Resolutions calling for non-cooperation of its members with the ICC, Requested by Coalition for the International Criminal Court, the Legal Defence and Assistance Project, the Civil Resource Development and Documentation Centre (CIRDDOC) and the Women Advocates Documentation Centre (WARDC)
Date 29 Nov 2015
Opinion Type Dissenting Opinion